Arguments Against Meritocracy. Dec 7, 2015 · The case against gender quotas often involves the
Dec 7, 2015 · The case against gender quotas often involves the argument of merit. Jan 22, 2025 · Diversity v Meritocracy in Organisations One of the (many) arguments that is ongoing in the organisation and DEI (diversity, equity and inclusion) spaces is that of diversity v meritocracy. Apr 23, 2021 · When sociologist Michael Young coined the term "meritocracy," he was warning against the idea that we should have to compete to prove how talented or hardworking we are. This idea is one of the most prevalent social and cultural tropes of our time, as palpable in the speeches of politicians as in popular culture. What are your arguments against meritocracy (ruler being chosen based on his merit instead of inheriting the position)? Thank… Jan 9, 2018 · Finally, the paper suggests a number of moral considerations on meritocracy vis-à-vis inequality and poverty, which will contribute towards correcting flawed conceptions of economic poverty and Meritocracy today involves the idea that whatever your social position at birth, society ought to offer enough opportunity and mobility for ‘talent’ to combine with ‘effort’ in order to ‘rise to the top’. Jun 29, 2001 · The book was a satire meant to be a warning (which needless to say has not been heeded) against what might happen to Britain between 1958 and the imagined final revolt against the meritocracy in 2033. The logic is that we should recruit on the basis of merit, not gender; quotas recruit on the basis of gender and so are by definition unmeritocratic. Well, look here’s the rest of Patrick’s question. They argue that the proletariat are persuaded to believe that the rich and powerful reached their positions through their hard work and natural ability rather than because of their privileged birth because this led them to accept inequality Sep 9, 2019 · In “The Meritocracy Trap,” Daniel Markovits delivers a fierce indictment of a system he says is undermining democracy and making everyone miserable. Oct 13, 2023 · Without it standing guard against racial inequity, we are left to wonder when anti-diversity conservatives will make their final blow against diversity efforts in the workplace and higher education institutions. According to Sandel, meritocracy has a dark side. The book is fantastic. Jan 27, 2025 · Jim Jump doesn’t buy David Brooks’s critique of the “meritocracy” but writes that his argument merits consideration nevertheless. Dec 8, 2018 · This argument was read by certain readers (and a few social media non-readers) as a paean to white privilege, even a brief for white supremacy. Indeed, when you think about America’s recent college admissions scandals, it is hard to claim that we live in a perfect meritocracy. Feb 9, 2022 · One of the most famous recent arguments against meritocracy was made by John Rawls in his famous book “A Theory of Justice” (1971), and it is sometimes referrred to as the original position or alternatively as the veil of ignorance. Jun 22, 2020 · What separates the two is luck. Aug 15, 2017 · In this book Jo Littler argues that meritocracy is the key cultural means of legitimation for contemporary neoliberal culture – and that whilst it promises opportunity, it in fact creates new forms of social division. Jan 5, 2021 · At a time when anger against elites has brought democracy to the brink, the question of merit takes on a special urgency. Sep 29, 2019 · It would be a mistake to read this critique of The Meritocracy Trap as an argument against reading the book. Jan 9, 2020 · In his book The Meritocracy Trap, Yale Law School’s Daniel Markovits argues that rather than democratizing American society, meritocracy has contributed to increasing inequality and the decline of the middle class. Myth of meritocracy Myth of meritocracy is a phrase arguing that meritocracy, or achieving upward social mobility through one's own merits regardless of one's social position, is not widely attainable in capitalist societies because of inherent contradictions. Sep 1, 2021 · In short, meritocracy was a moral and philosophical weapon against unfair hierarchy. Apr 20, 2020 · All in all, if the critics of meritocracy can’t present better arguments for ending it than Zaloom, Berg, and Douthat, maybe we should keep trying to let the hardest-working and most-talented people win, as best we can. Apr 5, 2021 · In fact, this argument is deeply flawed. He puts forth the claim that elite college admissions overrate rigged metrics of intelligence and, consequently, they produce a generational caste system with a class of elites who believe themselves Sep 1, 2021 · Taking down market meritocracy’s measure of merit requires deeper arguments than Sandel produces, and erecting an alternative measure of the common good poses a greater challenge than Sandel imagines. Feb 3, 2024 · DUCKWORTH: I haven’t read The Meritocracy Trap, but I’m pretty familiar with these arguments against meritocracy.